Haiku Society of America Rengay Awards for 2025 - Judges Commentary

Haiku Society of America Rengay Award
in Honor of Garry Gay

2025


Judged by
Jonathan Roman & Agnes Eva Savich

Comments reflect the combined
impressions of both judges.


 

2025 First Place

 

Current

sweat bees
drowned migrants
look up 

head down
they shave his hair

her grandpa's corrido
crying is part
of the joy 

ICE van idling
outside the taquería
a baker’s dozen

huddled masses
she knows it by heart 

they cross the river
with the moon
on their backs

 

Anton R–kelian, San Diego, CA 1, 3 & 5
Orense Nicod, Paris, France 2, 4 & 6

 

Poetry, no matter how timely or relevant, must still attempt to be good poetry. Thankfully, “Current” succeeds here. This rengay is titled perfectly, capturing layers of meaning with just one word, and every verse is heart-rending. The opening plunges us into a body of water with “drowned migrants”. “Huddled masses/she knows it by heart” alludes to the invitation inscribed at the base of the Statue of Liberty. The pursuit of this invitation is the subject of the beautiful closing verse as “they cross the river/with the moon/on their backs”.

 

2025 Second Place

 

Maiden Voyage

early morning mist
the shipwright's hands
pungent with oil

a whisper of white oak
curls from the blade

the dinghy
made of ancient Huon pine
rigged for a sail

tacking planks
to the steam-bent ribs
scent of red cedar

a last coat of varnish
warming twilight

starboard  side . . .
polishing the fog bell
for its maiden voyage

 

Ron C. Moss, Tasmania, Australia 1, 3 & 5
Paula Sears, Exter, New Hampshire 2, 4 & 6

 

The voyage begins in the “early morning mist”, alluding to uncertainty or danger. The authors add an element of yugen in the second verse: “a whisper of white oak curls from the blade”. “The dinghy made of ancient Huon pine” and “tacking planks to the steam-bent ribs” allows the reader to see the vessel not as something new, but something that has always been, something living. The final verse’s “polishing the fog bell” hearkens back to “the shipwright's hands pungent with oil” of the opening verse, making for a satisfying end to this rengay.

 


2025 Third Place


Between Worlds

deep in the marsh
one watches, one weaves
nest-making geese

a grey heron pauses
where the river bends

soft as fog
hard as seed
cattail fluff

clatter of white storks 
a courting dance
ruffles the reeds

half dead half living
lightning struck pine

empty duck blind
where a hunter’s shadow  
used to fall   

 

John Thompson, Sonoma, CA 1,3 & 5
Neena Singh, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India 2,4 & 6

 

Aptly titled, Between Worlds presents the reader with many images and instances of betweenness. From the pair of “nest making geese”, where “one watches” and “one weaves”, to the “lightning struck pine” stuck somewhere between life and death. The final haiku invites speculation as to the hunter’s fate, as it may be surmised that they are no longer around, clinging to life as the pine in the preceding verse.

 


2025 Honorable Mention 1


Emergence

swirl of gray
the traveler’s cloak
turns to mist

seeing shapes
in a starling murmuration

unexpected melody . . .
the shift
in my mood

taste of sunrise
orange sherbet
push-up pops

wandering the garden
a petal brushes my hand

grandma’s perfume . . .
I bend to inhale
pink lilacs

 

Mary McCormack, LaGrange Park, IL 1,3,& 5
Kathryn P. Haydon, Lake Bluff, IL 2,4 &6

 

The first half of this rengay works in tandem with the title to evoke a sense of intrigue that propels the reader forward. Each finely crafted haiku exudes mystery and poeticism, and there are elements of synaesthesia, pareidolia, personification, and other subtleties that conspire to endear the reader.

 

2025 Honorable Mention 2


3AM

Samhain—
the littlest witch
in her mother’s ashes

the creak of a cradle
from the ossuary

worm moon—
deep in his skull
black dahlias

hood’s shadow . . .
the upturned hand
of the mummy

around the corpse
swarm of scarabs

dust to dust . . .
the blue of her ghost
fogs the horizon

 

Rowan Beckett Minor, Cleveland, OH 1, 3 & 5
Joshua Gage, Cleveland, OH 2, 4 & 6

 

This rengay is perfectly titled, as it sets the mood for all that one can expect from the witching hour. 3AM manages to unsettle the reader with each successive image, culminating in a final haiku that is in keeping with the theme, yet attains a poignancy and beauty that is unexpected.

 

2025 Honorable Mention 3


Turn, Turn, Turn

sea smoke
urchin shells litter
the breakwater

the splay
of a tern’s wing feathers

snow glitter
tracking a mink
above the high-tide line

repositioning
what’s left of the hull
‘nother nor’easter

outer harbor
ice beads the mooring chain

circling
the keeper’s headstone
the automated beacon

 

Kristen Lindquist, Camden, ME 1,3,5
Alan S. Bridges, Westford, MA 2,4,6

 

Each one of this nautically-themed rengay’s haiku are a pleasure to read, and are chock full of cinematic elements. Besides the consistent theme, we are fans of the bittersweet ending, where the keeper's grave is ironically being watched over by the lighthouse he kept watch over.

 

About the 2025 Rengay Awards Judges

Agnes Eva Savich (Poland, 1976–) has been published in major journals, anthologized in several collections, and placed in contests in the U.S.A., Canada, England, and Japan since 2004. She is also a performing musician playing oboe in a woodwind quintet and local community orchestras, and she works in administration at The University of Texas at Austin. She has a daughter and a son. Her first haiku collection will be published in September 2025 by Red Moon Press.

Jonathan Roman hails from the Bronx, New York, and is still trying to wrap his head around being a human. When he is not in charge of his two smaller humans, he is covertly re-engaging with words. His poetry can be found in a number of haiku journals. The book he co-authored, After Amen: A Memoir In Two Voices, placed third in the 2022 Haiku Society of America's Merit Book Awards and was an Honorable Mention in The Haiku Foundation's 2021 Touchstone Awards. Connect with him on Bluesky: @deftnotes.bsky.social

~ ~ ~

 

 

 

 

These awards for unpublished rengay are sponsored by the Haiku Society of America in honor of Garry Gay, the inventor of rengay.

Winners by Year: | 2025 | 2024 | 2023 | 2022| 2021 | 2020 |

See the complete collection of award-winning haiku from all previous Rengay Award competitions

See the contest rules for entering the next Haiku Society of America Rengay Award competition. 

~ ~ ~

 

Ingredients We Look for in Exemplary Rengay:

by Garry Gay and Renee Owen

Adherence to Form – 2-person rengay (3/2/3/3/2/3) and 3-person rengay (3/2/3/2/3/2).

Compelling Themes – at least one discernable primary theme with a possible bonus for a secondary theme.

Universality of Meaning – why the poem matters and what it speaks to.

Effective Haiku – preferably strong haiku that carry enough weight to stand on their own.

Linking & Shifting – linking creates a pleasing flow, with 2-line stanzas linking well with the lines directly above and below, while the shift adds a new dimension.

Interesting Title – especially compelling if it doesn’t echo a line from the first few stanzas.

Exceptional Writing Style – incorporates poetic techniques, fresh imagery and word choices, a variety of sensory details, varied line/stanza structure, noteworthy sounds (like alliteration, consonance, etc.), avoids clichés and contains no spelling or grammatical errors.

Sense of Mystery or Something Left Unsaid—to engage and stimulate the reader.

Satisfactory Ending – a sense of completion and a possible link between the final and first stanza.

Multiple Rereadings – the poem continues to deepen and hold our interest.